Down on the Upside? Unpacking the current state of vertical consolidation

Explore the current state of vertical consolidation in healthcare as the industry faces escalating structural pressures that are shaking the foundation of the typical model.

Jordan Peterson
Jordan Peterson
15 min read

For years, vertical consolidation has been a mainstay of the insurer playbook—blending payer, provider, pharmacy, and PBM assets into a single, integrated ecosystem designed to drive synergies, provide consistent margin performance, and withstand turbulence to any one part of the business. It’s a strategy that worked remarkably well through the 2010s and early 2020s.

We may be reaching a turning point. Recent financial results across all national players—but especially from long-time market leader UnitedHealth Group—suggest that the flywheel of integration is spinning a bit off balance. The industry is experiencing a series of escalating structural pressures that are not expected to fade anytime soon. Nor are they pressures that the industry can simply wait out or push back against by protecting existing profit centers. Which brings us to our main question for exploration: Are insurers reaching the limits of vertical consolidation as a strategy?

Current state of health insurer consolidation

Let’s talk.

Questions? Want to learn more about what Union can do for you? We’d love to hear from you.