Are ICHRAs the next 401(k)s? Current trends in employer spending and employer adoption of ICHRAs

Explore the potential shift as employer adoption of ICHRAs mirrors the 401(k) transition. Discover how employer adoption of ICHRAs could redefine benefits.

Jordan Peterson
Jordan Peterson
17 min read

Healthcare costs are accelerating faster than anyone predicted, and employers are struggling to keep up. And our team has been having an internal debate about a scenario that seemed unlikely even just a few years ago: could employer-sponsored insurance (ESI) finally be approaching its defined contribution moment—echoing the pension-to-401(k) transition that reshaped retirement benefits a generation ago? Employers have long relied on ESI to attract and retain workers, but rising premiums, portability problems, and regulatory pressures are forcing them to re-think this approach. Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangements (ICHRAs) are emerging as one alternative option—and while adoption is still limited, the parallel to the 401(k) shift is striking. Both transitions reflect a consistent pattern: employers move toward defined contribution models for cost predictability, while workers take on more autonomy, portability, and risk. Let’s explore current trends and outlook in employer spending, the 401(k)/ICHRA parallel, its potential consequences, and what this all signals for the future of healthcare benefits.

State of employer-sponsored insurance (ESI)

Let’s start with a quick look at the state of employer spending and what’s going on with commercial insurance—important context for why we think a shift to ICHRAs is even a possibility at this point.

Let’s talk.

Questions? Want to learn more about what Union can do for you? We’d love to hear from you.